Coleman vs Jayco | Comparison Between Two RV Manufacturers

As an avid RV enthusiast researching options for my first trailer, I consistently came across two major manufacturers – Coleman and Jayco. Both have long histories in recreational vehicles and loyal customer bases. But they take notably different approaches, spanning cost, build materials, warranties, and more. 

I created this side-by-side comparison to help ensure buyers like myself make the most informed choice before investing in either brand.

Key Brand Backgrounds

Coleman

Coleman is best known for their camping gear – from tents to coolers. But they also have deep roots in manufacturing RV trailers and lightweight pop-ups since the 1960s when they acquired brands like Fleetwood and Gulfstream. Now owned by Dutchman, Coleman trailers have a reputation for being budget-friendly and easy to tow while providing all RV basics. But they don’t offer the creature comforts or the same build quality of more premium brands. Many longtime RV owners recall spending their early years in used Coleman models.

Jayco

Jayco emerged in the late 1960s as a maker of unique popup campers that gained quick popularity. They now stand among the world’s largest RV manufacturers across all vehicle classes – trailers, fifth wheels, toy haulers, and even Class A/Cs. Jayco has a great reputation for quality construction using fiberglass/aluminum/Azdel materials. This delivers better insulation and longevity than traditional wood framing. Jayco is now part of the Thor family of brands, which provides additional stability. However, with better quality and more robust construction come notably higher costs.

Now let’s take a look at this table below to find out what sets them apart:

Criteria	Coleman	Jayco
Price Range	$$ – Affordable, lower cost	$$$ – Mid to high range cost
Build Quality	Basic wood/aluminum construction	Up to 10,000 lbs for the largest fifth wheels
Insulation	Minimal, not for 4-season use	Excellent, suitable for all-weather use
Floorplans	Very limited (1-2 per model)	Extensive variety (20+ options)
Luxury Features	Very few included	Higher-end finishes and tech available
Tow Capacity Range	1,500-5,500 lbs	Buyers prioritize quality and full-timing
Warranty	1 year structure/2 year plumbing-electrical	3 year structure/2+3 years most components
Customer Service	Mixed reviews	Excellent reputation
Resale Value	Below average depreciation	Holds value exceptionally well
Best For…	Cost-conscious occasional RVers	Buyers prioritizing quality and full-timing

Trailer Options and Floorplans

Coleman

Coleman keeps trailer options fairly simple – just travel trailers and fifth wheels focused on lightweight design. Typical Coleman travel trailers span 20-28 feet in length. This includes a few basic bunkhouse floorplans or rear living designs optimized for family use. Inside heights run about 6’2”, making them feel pretty cramped compared to competitors. Coleman’s fifth wheels are slightly more spacious at 30-36 feet. But floorplan choices remain limited. Outside, you’ll see clean, simple exteriors lacking exciting graphics or paint options to customize your camper aesthetic.

Limited interior features

Reflecting their budget roots, Coleman interiors don’t include luxuries or tech found in mid-range units. Think simple countertops and cabinets, basic appliances, manual climate systems, no fireplaces or TVs included. They meet the need but lack pizzazz. However, 2020 models improved insulation for four seasons usability.

Jayco

True to their reputation, Jayco offers endless trailer configuration options across sizes and budgets. Even their most affordable J-series span 20+ layouts from rear sofas to side aisles to convertible bunks. Step up to Jay Flight lines and you have over 50 floorplans under 35 feet mixing private master suites, mid bunks, rear bunks, and spacious living areas. Then you reach the pinnacle Pinnacle line with slide-outs, fireplaces, recliners, and premium everything. Compared to Coleman, it’s no contest when it comes to choices. And interior features match the quality, with excellent use of space, upscale décor, and the latest tech.

Construction, Components, and Capabilities

Coleman

As mentioned, Coleman builds trailers focused on affordability using standard materials – wood framing, aluminum exteriors, and basic appliances/fixtures. While functional and light, the build quality means fewer years of comfortable use for full-time RVing compared to better-built brands. I came across occasional complaints of soft floors over time. And winter camping is only suitable with additional insulation add-ons based on owner reviews. Average Coleman trailer capacities run 1,500 to 5,500 lbs, able to fit most tow vehicles. Just don’t expect robust construction or durability in rough conditions. But for part-time vacationing, they check the box.

Jayco

Constructing trailers with fiberglass/aluminum/Azdel not only delivers superior insulation but exceptional durability over thousands of miles. This quality extends across components like thicker countertops, stainless steel fixtures, and name-brand appliances. Plus you gain technology like the JRide suspension system for smoother towing. As a result, Jayco RVs better retain their structure and value for full-timing or resale. Of course, quality comes at a cost. But tow ratings up to 10,000 pounds for robust fifth wheels reward buyers willing to invest more initially.

Types of RVs Offered

Coleman

Coleman RV focuses exclusively on travel trailers and fifth wheels. Their simple, lightweight trailer models typically span 20-28 feet while fifth wheels run 30-36 feet. Coleman also manufactures some basic toy hauler models designed to transport motorcycles, ATVs, etc. But overall, their range is very limited compared to Jayco.

Jayco

Meanwhile, Jayco is an RV powerhouse producing everything from small camping pop-ups to mammoth Class A motorhomes. Their travel trailers, fifth wheels, and toy haulers come in endless configurations and sizes up to 40+ feet. Unique to Jayco, they also build Class C and Class A motorized RVs along with expandable tent trailers. So Jayco provides far more variety across RV categories.

Warranty Considerations

Coleman

Basic limited warranties from Coleman leave much to be desired compared to other brands. Structural coverage spans just 12 months, while plumbing/electrical extends to two years. Appliances and components like ACs typically come with individual manufacturers’ warranties for around a year. This leaves owners on the hook for issues after relatively short windows. For budget-conscious buyers willing to replace aging trailers in 5-7 years, minimal Coleman warranties pose little issue. But they don’t inspire confidence for longer-term ownership or use cases.

Jayco

Here’s where Jayco clearly dominates over Coleman – their renowned warranty program goes far beyond industry norms. Structural coverage reaches a full 3 years, which is very rare. Jayco also pioneered their 2+3 year warranty on most components, covering years 2-5 for added peace of mind. Individual items like ACs or refrigerators fall under separate manufacturer warranties. For buyers like myself wanting to invest in a lifetime trailer to use for 10+ years, Jayco’s reputable warranty provides tremendous financial protection. It meaningfully justifies the increased upfront spending.

Customer Service Reputation

Coleman

As a value brand, Coleman owners don’t expect white-glove treatment when issues arise. Response times to questions or needed repairs run slower than premium manufacturers. But as long as you set proper expectations around their position in the market, customer service experiences seem adequate to me. Cost-conscious buyers put up with the trade-offs. However, I read occasional gripes of poorly handled warranty issues compared to brands like Jayco with more customer care infrastructure.

Jayco

With an extensive dealer network and immense company scale, most reviewers describe Jayco’s customer service as excellent. Their motorhome club rallies and owner events also promote community. My research found numerous examples of Jayco going above and beyond handling warranty repairs or accommodating special owner requests post-purchase. And critical online reviews seldom take issue with how Jayco supports products when problems occur. As an industry leader, their reputation for standing behind RVs keeps buyers loyal across generations.

Which One is Best For You?

Determining if a Coleman or Jayco RV is the better choice comes down to properly matching the brand to your needs and priorities as a buyer. Ask yourself the following key questions:

1. What’s your budget? 

If getting an affordable starter RV is your main goal, Coleman offers the lowest buy-in pricing and good basic features. Jayco is the premium play requiring more upfront investment.

2. How soon do you plan to upgrade? 

Minimal warranties and build quality mean most Coleman owners upgrade in 5-7 years. Jayco’s durable construction and protections reward long-term ownership.

3. What kind of trips do you take? 

Frequent short regional trips allow you to access Coleman’s lighter towing and setup. Extended full-timing across seasons suits Jayco’s all-weather insulation.

4. How adventurous is your lifestyle? 

Coleman provides basic amenities for temporary shelter while traveling. Jayco opens more possibilities like outdoor living or specialized sports hauling.

5. Do you value luxury features and styling? 

If you want a flashy, resort-like interior packed with upgrades, Jayco interiors easily beat Coleman’s simplicity.

Carefully weighing your budget, planned usage, and must-have functionality makes choosing the right brand much clearer. Coleman appeals to cost-conscious weekend warriors. Jayco takes the prize for higher standards around luxury and livability. Match your RV to your lifestyle and adventure goals.

FAQs – Frequently Asked Questions

Still deciding between Coleman and Jayco trailers? These buyer FAQs may help tip your decision

Which brand offers better resale value?

Jayco models historically retain higher resale value across ages and classes thanks to quality construction.

Can either brand be financed?

Yes – both Coleman and Jayco dealers provide financing options and arrangements to purchase new models. Jayco sometimes runs special rates or incentives.

Are Coleman trailers good for full-time living?

Coleman’s build quality and insulation fall short of comfortable 4-season or year-round occupation compared to rivals. Best for part-time vacationing.

Does Jayco make toy hauler travel trailers?

Yes, Jayco toy hauler lines like Octane, Seismic, and Talon serve RVers with motorized hobbies needing garage space.

The Bottom Line

After closely evaluating Coleman and Jayco brands side-by-side, I reached my verdict. Coleman offers tremendous upfront cost savings on trailers meeting basic needs for weekend warriors not demanding lavish features. But Jayco takes the crown as my top choice to invest in higher quality construction and comforts I’ll enjoy for the long haul. Their resale value, warranties, choices, and towability ultimately justify spending more. Though Coleman works perfectly for many RV owners on tighter budgets or with simpler needs from a trailer. You can’t go wrong with either brand – align your priorities and camping style with the option of delivering the best value. Both provide great avenues to explore the open road!